Back to the front page
Every review · real and word for word

All 4 reviews.

Every one of them, below. Pick a phrase to read the reviews that speak to it.

everything4knows the area3is easy to reach2
Every review4 reviews
Jay was so great to work with.

He was really calm and even tempered. He gave us insight into the market and I really appreciated that he didn't pressure us to offer "more, more, more" just so we could get a rental. He wanted to make sure that we were getting a good investment and not just offering a ridiculous amount over asking just so we could get a property. I felt like he cared about us for the long term. I would recommend Jay!

intricategirl1 · Nov 2016
We found Jay to be extremely pleasant and easy to work with.

Stayed in touch with us for over a year since we lived out of town and kept us informed as to what was going on in the market. We enjoyed his quick wit and since of humor. I would highly recommend him.

baggasfunkyfinds · Apr 2016
My husband and I have worked with Jay to help us find our first home, and then again when the time came to sell it.

Jay was attentive, honest, and extremely helpful every step of the way. He was great at explaining some of the complexities in our contracts and was always able to get a laugh or two out of us at some of the most stressful times in our lives. He is genuine and always had our best interest in mind. We were in great hands with Jay, and I cannot recommend his services enough!

Linda L. · Jul 2026
We had a really tight timeline for our relocation and I was honestly stressed about finding the right place so quickly.

Jay made the whole move go super smooth though - he had such great market knowledge and really listened to what we needed. His responsiveness was amazing and he handled all the details while keeping us calm throughout everything. Would definitely recommend Jay to anyone looking in this area!

Tiffany · Jun 2026
One small ask

Thinking about making a move?

Tell Jay what you're thinking about — you'll get what the numbers say, even when the answer is "wait."

(970) 443-1042
Call or text, Jay answers · or email Jay
Jay McCoy
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Rocky Mountain Realtors · (970) 443-1042 · jay_mccoy@msn.com
Site by Listing Leads
Jay McCoy is a licensed real estate agent with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Rocky Mountain Realtors (Lic. #1047985). Market numbers are believed accurate but not guaranteed; verify anything important independently. Nothing on this site is an appraisal or a promise of value. If your home is already listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation.
© 2026 Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Rocky Mountain Realtors · Serving Larimer and Weld CountiesEQUAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITYREALTOR®Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Rocky Mountain Realtors